You’ve Been Trumped: Documenting Donald Trump’s Scottish Incursion

You've Been Trumped (2011

You’ve Been Trumped (2011

The title could just about sum up this blood-boiling 2011 documentary directed by Anthony Baxter and produced and co-written by Richard Phinney, a festival fave finally released on DVD a few months ago. At face value, it’s a gritty, ground-level film witness to Donald Trump’s unsubtle tactics in pushing through plans to build an enormous jet-set golf resort near a pristine stretch of coastline north of Aberdeen. The filmmaker’s sympathies are clear as a group of local residents, who have the audacity to own humble properties in the path of the tycoon’s grandiose scheme, refuse to budge—even in the face of a government Compulsory Purchase Order (eminent domain). The starry-eyed deferment to fame and fortune in its modern media-age manifestation provides the film’s rich subtext.

The Aberdeenshire regional council at first rejects the plan but after the Scottish Parliament “calls in” that decision, the project is approved, despite the site’s official designation as a grade-one conservation area. Baxter shoots a scene at a Trump-attended groundbreaking event, where fawning local officials and business people realize that there lives are being touched by an actual Celebrity, and one ready to throw a lot of money around. A nearby college, not to be outdone, desperately bestows Trump with an honorary degree even as credible experts warn of the steep environmental cost.

Throughout You’ve Been Trumped Baxter inserts scenes from Bill Forsyth’s amiable (and analogous) 1983 fiction film Local Hero. There, the plans of an American oil baron (Burt Lancaster) to buy out a coastal enclave and replace it with a refinery are complicated when the hotshot executive he sends there as an advance party (Peter Riegert) is lured by the charms of the village’s slow-lane lifestyle. How quaint. Nowadays, a guy like “The Donald” doesn’t have to waste his time courting skeptical residents. According to him, the property of Michael Forbes, the flinty old-school farmer who’s at the forefront of local resistance, is “slum-like and disgusting” and the man “lives like a pig.” Trump has always liked to come on like a streetwise New Yorker (despite his silver spoon) and his blustering reputation precedes him by a country mile. This kick-out-the-poor attitude is less objectionable nowadays where (notably in the U.S.) a certain obsessive fixation on wealth and fame has elevated the likes of him to an iconic status that often “trumps” any solidarity one may have once felt with the general population.

You've Been Trumped Donald Trump

With the skids greased by the city fathers, who seem to have imported this mindset, Trump quickly moves in. His earthmovers are soon moving “biblical” amounts of sand to make way for the two 18-hole golf courses, depositing one of Britain’s largest sand dune systems next to the homes of those who don’t like him and encroaching on their property lines. In one of the film’s more telling scenes, the local police arrest Baxter (and rather roughly at that) for filming an interview with project opponent Susan Munro, in her own driveway.

It’s true that for certain socio-political types (like those partial to muckraking documentaries) a figure like Trump will remain an easy target of scorn. He’s the conceited blowhard whose self-titled building projects blight the old majesty of Manhattan, the condescending candidate whose short-lived run for the American presidency rested on the despicable “birther” platform, the TV host of “Celebrity Apprentice” who gets his jollies watching washed-up stars like Gary Busey and Meatloaf grovel from the other side of a mahogany conference table. To a person like Susan Munro, Trump is no more than someone “with a few pounds in his pocket and a bit of a name.”  The question coursing through the film is whether her outlook, serving as a great leveler when multiplied across the body politic, will win out or will more people imagine that they are just a lottery win or reality-show appearance or viral video away from joining Donald in the gentrified ranks of the 1%.

Donald TrumpWhile the intrepid Baxter is tracking down Trump at press conferences and parliamentary hearings, the opponents attract a group of sympathizers who flock to a protest march and to a Trump-mocking art show held in a barn on Forbes’ farm. One of them is Mickey Foote, who in another lifetime was producer of the Clash’s first album. Now living near-by, Foote speaks knowingly about the limits of Forbes’ newfound local celebrity vs. Trump’s international stature and to what’s being lost in the deal (“a fantastic open space within reach of ordinary people.”) These scenes of citizen camaraderie may be seen as gratifying but one can only be left thinking what the future holds in an age of gaping income inequality that forms the broader background of this theme. While Trump gloats about the few hundred service-sector positions available at his resort, we’re seemingly left with an untouchable upper class run amuck in a return to a medieval-style oligarchy, with government and law enforcement in their pocket. You’ve Been Trumped smartly plays out this frightening scenario in miniature.

 

About the Author

Rick Ouellette is an indie author based in the Boston area whose first book, Documentary 101: A Viewer’s Guide to Non-Fiction Film, was published in 2013. With any luck the follow-up, a survey of rock music docs, will see the light of day in 2014.

Find out more: http://rickouellettereelandrock.wordpress.com/

Rick Ouellette is a freelance writer from Boston, Mass. His new book, Rock Docs: A Fifty-Year Cinematic Journey, 1964-2014 is available for sale online. Rick writes about rock music, documentary film and pop culture miscellany on his blog Reel and Rock. Go to http://rickouellettereelandrock.wordpress.com/ for more info.

5 thoughts on “You’ve Been Trumped: Documenting Donald Trump’s Scottish Incursion

  1. Great analysis. I’ll have to watch the documentary, then. I find it frightening that truthful things like this documentary can be produced and publicly available, yet have very little chance of actually undermining or weakening powerful individuals like Trump in any way. Historians have often considered “elite control” as a viable theoretical approach to our past, and I fear that it it is fast becoming the most germane theory to explain contemporary history.

  2. I have seen this film, and your appraisal is just right. As someone from the UK, increasingly disheartened by the Americanisation of our populace, and much of our country, I can only feel depressed at the ease with which this sort of thing is allowed, indeed actively courted, by a nation that is fast losing its identity, and willing to sell what little is left.
    I can only hope that the Scots do vote for independence, than nationalise Trump’s holdings. Sadly, I fear that this is unlikely.
    (What is going on with his hair, by the way?)
    Regards from England, Pete.

  3. Nice piece, Rick. I am excited to see you hear as a guest writer on Curnblog. You and I havent appeared in the same publication since Video Eyeball, and that was 20 years ago. I trust everything is going well with you.

    • Thanks, Bill. After reading your Kubrick piece, I thought your name looked familiar, esp. after the reference to Boston. Still living in the area and doing well. It’s great to hear from you and look forward to reading more of your work

Leave a Reply