Leaving Home: Ten films about migration

The immigrantI was recently asked to put together a post on films that deal with the experience of migration by a friend who is about to take the big plunge. Of course, this is a huge topic. People migrate for all sorts of reasons, and so the experience is hardly a unified one. The act of leaving behind what one knows for an entirely new frontier can be an act of hope that brings about fresh beginnings, a means of escaping from tyranny or oppression, or of course there is the ultimate final migration and whatever that might entail (depending on what you believe).

So without further ado, here are ten films that encapsulate some of the many incarnations that the migration experience can take.

 

 

 

1. The Immigrant (1917)

Where better to start than with Charlie Chaplin’s classic short on the difficult and yet hopeful experience of migrating to the United States? Chaplin is at his finest when he achieves a perfect balance of social commentary and comedic ingenuity and this film is certainly a demonstration of that. From the boat ride over, to the struggle to maintain dignity in a foreign (and not always welcoming) land, Chaplin’s film is a great window into the rewards and complexities of starting again without a cent to your name.

2. The Adventures of Barry McKenzie (1972)

Not so much a story of migration as that of a pilgrimage, this is the irreverent tale of an Aussie bloke (Barry Crocker) who finds himself unwillingly going on a trip to England with his aunt Edna (Barry Humphries). The film is loaded with a savage critique of both Australian and English culture at the time, and people offended by the coarser side of humour should probably give it a miss. The closest American equivalent would probably be South Park.

(And yes, Aunt Edna’s character carries on beyond the McKenzie films and eventually becomes Dame Edna.)

3. The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada (2005)

When a Texan man’s best friend, an illegal immigrant, is murdered, he takes the culprit hostage and forces him to carry the body across the border into Mexico for a proper burial. A powerful film that shines a light on the indignity and disempowerment that comes with living in a place where your rights aren’t fully recognised.

4. Total Recall (1990)

Well before Phillip K. Dick’s short story, We Can Remember It for You Wholesale, was butchered in the 2012 version of the film, Verhoeven’s action masterpiece cemented itself as one of the seminal examples of the Hollywood action/sci-fi genre. Using Schwarzenegger to good effect, this is the story of a man’s inexplicable desire to migrate to the planet Mars and start afresh. Verhoeven artfully constructs a film that reflects Dick’s own discombobulating sensibilities: What is real? What is a dream? Is this actually happening? Does it matter? Big questions for a film comprised largely of machine gun fire, and yet they are asked more skilfully than in many films that choose to tackle the topic directly.

5. Bandit Queen (1994)

This is the true story (although its accuracy is hotly debated) of Phoolan Devi, an Indian woman born into social circumstances that she could not tolerate. At a young age, the unusually aggressive Devi finds herself married off to a man that she despises. When she goes too far in her open contempt of her situation, Devi is completely ostracised and must build a new life. She goes on to lead a group of bandits and eventually becomes something of folk-hero, and finally, after much struggle, a significant political figure. The savagery with which Devi contended (and eventually dealt out) is more than I could possibly articulate here, but this film about escaping oppression is worth a look. (Devi was assassinated in 2001)

6. The Godfather: Part Two (1974)

It would be crazy to have a list of films on the topic of migration without including this one. Coppola’s epic meditation on the corrupting potential of the American dream continues here, with the story now split between the ongoing expansion of Michael Corleone’s criminal empire and the tale of his father’s migration to the United States some seventy years earlier. A vivid depiction of late 19th and early 20th century America, this is easily one of the greatest American films ever made.

7. The Party (1968)

Peter Seller’s The Party is now quite regressive in terms of its depictions of race, but there’s no denying the brilliant comedic force of this one-man masterpiece. Seller’s plays Hrundi V. Bakshi, an Indian man who has moved to America to commence a career in Hollywood. Unfortunately, Bakshi’s bumbling ways have him fired from his job as an extra on a big budget film set. Luckily, a clerical error sees Bakshi invited to an exclusive Hollywood party. It is at this party where the vast majority of the film takes place, with Bakshi’s clumsy antics constantly thwarting his own mission to network with the Hollywood elite. Special stuff.

8. Les Visiteurs (1993)

In this French classic, a knight (Jean Reno) and his squire (Christian Clavier) make the ultimate migration when a senile wizard moves them 1000 years through time to the 20th century. Most of the comedic quality comes from watching the time travellers misinterpret the modern world at every turn. Lots of fun.

9. Night on Earth (1991)

Not so much a film about migration as a migrating film, Jim Jarmusch’s Night on Earth is a collection of five stories about taxi trips happening at the same time in five different parts of the world. A huge cast of actors come together to create this wonderful (if sometimes uneven) meditation on the consistency of the human experience. Worth a look.

10. The Seventh Seal (1957)

This masterwork from Ingmar Bergman is widely recognised as one of the great examinations of life’s ultimate act of migration, death. As the plague sweeps through medieval Sweden, its horrors force a knight (Max von Sydow) to start question the meaning of existence. When the Grim Reaper appears, the knight engages with him in a game of chess to secure his own life. Absolutely cannot be missed.

James Curnow is an obsessive cinephile and the owner and head editor of CURNBLOG. His work as a film journalist has been published in a range of print and digital publications, including The Guardian, Broadsheet and Screening the Past. James is currently working through a PhD in Film Studies, focused primarily on issues of historical representation in Contemporary Hollywood cinema.

37 thoughts on “Leaving Home: Ten films about migration

  1. Thanks for stopping by; great to cyber-meet someone who loves movies too! Great list here … am taking note of several to check out. I would add 1992’s “Far and Away” to the Migration stories!

  2. Thank you for following my own wobbly efforts; your posts are superb. If I may offer up one additional migration film: Easy Rider (1967?) It certainly made an impression on me at the time! Please continue to keep up the good work; I’ll keep visiting!

    • Thank YOU! Actually, I wouldn’t consider your efforts wobbly at all – love the latest piece. I’m currently pulling something together on Eastwood’s ‘J. Edgar’ so it was particularly interesting to read that one.

      Easy Rider – absolutely. Good call.

  3. Pingback: About | Curnblog | Hey Sweetheart, Get Me Rewrite!

  4. Hmmm… there are at least three films here that i’ve never even heard of before… thank you for expanding both my horizons and my ‘must see’ list!

  5. Thank you for this, and for stopping by… there are several films here i’ve never even heard of before, so thank you for expanding both my horizons and my ‘must see’ list. I’ll be back…

  6. Several of my favorites here! I LOVED Total Recall, was always a bit embarassed by this. Thanks for making it okay to believe it’s a great film. The Party and Godfather II also have honoured places on our shelves. I will have to try to see some of these others now. Particularly The Seventh Seal and Night on Earth. My curiousity is piqued! On to my Ziplist they go!

  7. Reblogged this on heyyounglondon and commented:
    I recently asked a film-buff friend to look into right of passage movies, or films that focus on relocating.

    James has come up with 10 brilliant films – some I’ve seen, and others I haven’t, that look at this theme. Check out his very well researched and thoughtful post via http://www.curnblog.com.

    Thanks again James for this great blog post!

  8. Hi James,
    Great article as always, and well-researched. ‘Three Burials’ is a real gem, and little known outside the world of the film buff. As usual, I would like to offer some additions to the list!

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0978759/ Frozen River, a very atmospheric film, unusually set in a Native American community.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093713/?ref_=sr_1 Pelle The Conqueror. This film dates from 1987, and stars the Swedish grand actor, Max Von Sydow, alongside the young Pelle Hvenegaard, in the title role. It deals with Swedish migration in the early 1900′s, on this occasion to Denmark, looking for work, and hoping to escape certain poverty in their homeland. This is a film dealing with a familiar subject in an unfamiliar setting once again, and follows events almost unknown outside Sweden and Denmark. The immigrant Swedes are treated badly by their Danish employers, and regarded as unwanted itinerants by the population as a whole. They struggle on the farms, lorded over by cruel overseers, and working in all weathers. Pelle manages to learn to speak Danish, but still gets little acceptance; and his father is too old, and too bitter, to make any progress in this promised land of work and opportunity. The old man eventually finds some solace, with the wife of a sailor, lost at sea, thus giving Pelle the chance to move on, and escape the harsh life. A touching, yet powerful film, beautifully shot, and a real escape from the run of the mill.

    Finally, a somewhat sentimental, but nonetheless interesting view, of the entry into the USA for so many immigrants. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0465188/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1 ‘Golden Door’, also known as ‘New World’, and ‘Ellis Island’.

    Your selection is an interesting take on the idea of migration/immigration, and I really enjoyed reading it. Regards from England, Pete.

  9. thanks for stopping by- funnily enough, i’m celebrating today- just become a citizen of Australia after moving 5 years ago from Scotland ! reason- better life for my daughter. 🙂

Leave a Reply